Loading...
|| News ||
Share EMAIL PRINT POST COMMENT(19)
 
Page 1 of 1

YouTube Censors Lesbian Kiss


Censored Double Rainbow x390 (grab) | ADVOCATE.COM

Google-owned video hosting site YouTube ordered Second City Network, the popular comedy group, to censor one of its skits that showed lesbians kissing.

Second City, the group that created the famous “Sassy Gay Friend,” devised the skit as a spoof on another video by “Bear” Vasquez that features a hiker’s enthusiastic commentary as he films a rainbow in Yosemite National Parl. Second City used the sound from that video in its parody, playing on the term “double rainbow” as a term for lesbians kissing.

In the video’s description, the group posts, “YouTube decided that two girls kissing is inappropriate, and flagged our video! So we uploaded a "CLEAN FOR YOUTUBE" censored version. If you think YouTube is Homophobic, leave a comment below!”

The uncensored version is still available on YouTube but requires that users sign in — a process that is tied to age verification from the account’s creation.

YouTube introduces its community guidelines by stating, “We're not asking for the kind of respect reserved for nuns, the elderly, and brain surgeons.” Its content regulations are to be expected: no pornography, drug use, gratuitous violence, copyrighted media, spam, etc.

The censorship of the "Double Rainbow" video is surprising given the nature of some of YouTube's other videos. A cursory search of “lesbian make out” yields seven pages of results, many of which are taken from published pornographic videos (a double violation of the guidelines). Some of these videos have view counts in the millions, and many do not require logging in.

The site’s process of removal is rooted in the viewers, who are asked to “flag” any video that may offend them and that violates the terms of use. After a video has been flagged, it is reviewed by YouTube staff, who “review flagged videos 24 hours a day, seven days a week to determine whether they violate our Community Guidelines.”

Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Twitter. Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Facebook. Page 1 of 1
Share EMAIL PRINT POST COMMENT(19)
 
Reader Comments
  • Name: Victor
    Date posted: 8/11/2010 11:46:20 AM
    Hometown: Washington, D.C.

    Comment:

    I've had the same thing happen to me on Youtube, Facebook, and Ebay. I've posted a Youtube clip about what just happened to me on Facebook on August 10, 2010. The link to the clip is http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SqnWY6aERjg

  • Name: Fred Stanley
    Date posted: 7/31/2010 2:40:53 AM
    Hometown: Palm Springs, CA

    Comment:

    YouTube would probably censor the second coming of Jesus Christ!!!

  • Name: Donald Von Boeckman
    Date posted: 7/30/2010 7:52:22 PM
    Hometown: Cordova, Tn

    Comment:

    I totally lost my respect for Google for flagging something as innocent as 2 females kissing. I agree that if they are going to restrict lesbian and gay men who kiss, then let's include it to censor all kissing. After all, kissing someone of the same sex is murdurously wrong. Damned Disgusting in this century that we still have to tolerate being treated second class. No, there is not liberty and justice for all Americans, that kid in Arkansas is correct. Sad but true.

  • Name: Davin
    Date posted: 7/30/2010 3:34:46 PM
    Hometown: Los Angeles

    Comment:

    Just the other day I went to YouTube to watch the "I Want to Break Free" Queen video and was shocked when YouTube said it was flagged as being unappropriate. And than asked me to prove I was an adult. Really!?!

  • Name: Charles
    Date posted: 7/30/2010 3:04:33 PM
    Hometown: Rock Hill, SC

    Comment:

    …nothing better to capture attention on YouTube than to use the words: Banned, Censored, Too Hot for American TV, etc. in the title.

  • Name: Charles
    Date posted: 7/30/2010 3:02:28 PM
    Hometown: Rock Hill, SC

    Comment:

    Advocate News Fail! Definitely a publicity stunt. There are plenty of pretty hot uncensored gay and lesbian kissing scenes on YouTube. (Also, it's Yosemite National Park, not Parl.) I'm really starting to get tired with the non-news items on Advocate.com.

  • Name: MWA
    Date posted: 7/29/2010 6:45:26 PM
    Hometown: Manhattan

    Comment:

    It would be wonderful if google/youtube received a mass number of requests that they censor ALL kissing if they're going to censor lesbian kissing. I mean, really. The ONLY way this would be nondiscriminatory is if that happened. Either censor all kissing or don't censor it at all. It's kissing, not nudity, pornography, or gratuitous pointless sex. Theres worse in most PG rated films. Homophobic ignorant bureaucratic twits.

  • Name: Gray
    Date posted: 7/29/2010 6:38:26 PM
    Hometown: Minneapolis

    Comment:

    @Dan: Sweetie, just come out already. You're not fooling anyone.

  • Name: Gray
    Date posted: 7/29/2010 6:29:10 PM
    Hometown: Minneapolis

    Comment:

    @Dan: Sweetie, just come out already. You're not fooling anyone.

  • Name: Nicola Megaw
    Date posted: 7/29/2010 6:25:16 PM
    Hometown: Timaru, New Zealand

    Comment:

    This is the biggest load of bullshit i have heard in a while. ffs youtube your willing to have lots of porn on your site and a lot of videos where woman are kissing each other. type in "lesbian kisses from movies" and you will get a lot of hits. But you state that two woman kissing is "porn" what a crock of shit. its homophobes like youtube that set us back 30+ years. Its bad enough that i have to see hetro's kissing each other on tv and in person lol but to say that woman kissing each other is porn is shit. its 2010 not 1950. its about time the rest of the world accept lgbt peeps as WE ARE NOT GOING ANYWHERE!!!!!.



More Online Only
  • Commentary The Imaginary Debate

    Actor and blogger Chad Lindsey asks, if the secular and devout can comfortably share space at a drive-in theater in Michigan, why can’t the political right share lower Manhattan?

  • Commentary Cross Country Speed Dating

    Would you like to go on a date with this guy? Kevin Patrick Richberg tells you how you can make it happen, and why he's hitting up 30 states in 30 days to find Mr. Right.

  • Internet Video Content Flag Ruffling Some (Peacock) Feathers

    Fresh from attracting 3 million viewers to his "California Gays" video, Ryan James Yezak ups the budget and takes on another Katy Perry tune — the very gay "Peacock."

  • Television Hear What Happens Live

    Fresh off his Emmy win for Top Chef, Bravo executive Andy Cohen talks about Monday night's Real Housewives of New Jersey reunion and being shoved by a table-flipper.

  • Fitness The New 60

    Psychotherapist and Advocate columnist Robert Levithan looks back on his life experiences and finds the journey to personal truth can be complicated and rewarding.

  • Washington D C View From Washington

    The White House may continue to wear blinders on same-sex marriage, but the world is transforming around them as conservatives take up the mantle of equality.

  • DVDs The Hot Sheet

    Katy Perry secures her gay fan base, J. Lo finds her Back-Up Plan, the latest adaptation of Dorian Gray stays gay, and Heart returns for the first time in six years.

  • Health and Treatments Living the Questions

    Living the questions takes takes on a literal meaning as Advocate columnist Tyler Helms describes the day he almost lost everything after being diagnosed with HIV.

  • Theater On the Road With Laramie

    As Greg Pierotti heads into rehearsal with Laramie 10 Years Later, he finds the people of Laramie are eager for their city to be known as something more wholesome than the scene of a hate crime.

  • News Features Mason Wyler Comes Clean

    Porn star Mason Wyler has never been shy about his sex drive — which is why he says he expected mixed response to his announcement that he's HIV-positive.

  • News Features Swim Team

    Swimming three miles between Long Island and Fire Island this weekend, 50 people raised big bucks for gay charities. Check out photos from the the Stonewall Foundation's second annual swim here.

  • Style Canine Couture

    Sparkly accessories, witty T-shirts, and cute capes — New York's Pet Fashion Week let the dogs run the show. Check out the photos.

  • Washington D C View From Washington

    On LGBT and mainstream issues alike, the Obama administration finds progressives irritating. But they let their frustration insulate them from criticism at their own peril on marriage equality.

  • DVDs Video Content Flag The Hot Sheet

    Jerry O'Connell strips down to fend off piranhas, Anthony Hopkins plays gay for Ivory, Jennifer Aniston takes on Bill O'Reilly, and Mad Men undress.

  • Television Come Away With Me

    Flip on the cruise control and discover the nooks and crannies of America with travel show host David Keeps.

  • Media Video Content Flag Advocate On-Air: GLAAD Edition

    What do Sigourney Weaver, Adam Lambert, and Mississippi high schooler Constance McMillen have in common? To find out, watch The Advocate On-Air's Special GLAAD Edition.

  • Books One Night with Valentino

    Book excerpt: In Secret Historian, Justin Spring’s biography of “professor, tattoo artist and sexual renegade” Samuel Steward, a torrid tryst with screen legend Rudolph Valentino is revealed.

  • Marriage Equality White House Meeting Heats Up

    A White House meeting with state equality organizations has inflamed the blogosphere after LGBT Liaison Brian Bond said he was frustrated with bloggers criticisizing an administration that is "99 percent" supportive on equality issues.

  • Theater Seat Filler

    Your man on the New York theater scene RSVPs to Abraham Lincoln’s Big Gay Dance Party, spends A Night at the Tombs with a trans celeb, and checks out the old/new faces in A Little Night Music.

  • Media Mama's Got Something to Tell You

    Progressive radio darling Stephanie Miller knows she shocked some fans by coming out, but the sharp-tongued liberal wants everyone to know she's still a single, childless loser.

Facebook Activity