Issue Number 1005 | Labor of Love | Advocate.com Labor of Love  |  | Advocate.com

Health Promo 03 (Getty) | Advocate.com
||  First Person  ||
 

Labor of Love

Is society ready for this pregnant husband?
From The Advocate  April 8, 2008
 Labor of Love

To our neighbors, my wife, Nancy, and I don’t appear in the least unusual. To those in the quiet Oregon community where we live, we are viewed just as we are -- a happy couple deeply in love. Our desire to work hard, buy our first home, and start a family was nothing out of the ordinary. That is, until we decided that I would carry our child.

I am transgender, legally male, and legally married to Nancy. Unlike those in same-sex marriages, domestic partnerships, or civil unions, Nancy and I are afforded the more than 1,100 federal rights of marriage. Sterilization is not a requirement for sex reassignment, so I decided to have chest reconstruction and testosterone therapy but kept my reproductive rights. Wanting to have a biological child is neither a male nor female desire, but a human desire.

Ten years ago, when Nancy and I became a couple, the idea of us having a child was more dream than plan. I always wanted to have children. However, due to severe endometriosis 20 years ago, Nancy had to undergo a hysterectomy and is unable to carry a child. But after the success of our custom screen-printing business and a move from Hawaii to the Pacific Northwest two years ago, the timing finally seemed right. I stopped taking my bimonthly testosterone injections. It had been roughly eight years since I had my last menstrual cycle, so this wasn’t a decision that I took lightly. My body regulated itself after about four months, and I didn’t have to take any exogenous estrogen, progesterone, or fertility drugs to aid my pregnancy.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3

Reader Comments

These comments are reproduced as written by visitors to this Web site. They have not been edited for content, grammar, or spelling. The viewpoints appearing here are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or views of advocate.com, The Advocate, or its affiliates.

  • Name: Truth
    Date posted: 2009-01-01 1:53 PM
    Hometown: Southfield

    Comment:

    Mr. or Mrs - It doesn't matter. What we all need to understand is that you are a very selfish person. Hiding behind a veil of pain, and difficulties is just a self-serving deception to somehow justify your desires to the public. Listen LADY - cutting off your breasts and getting injections does not change how you were born. It is another self-serving need such as that stemming from masochism. I feel sorry that you have not come to grips with any of your issues - taking such extreme measures to avoid recognizing your real purpose is a shame. All this is done out of a deep self-serving avoidance of deep unresolved issues. What a shame - I feel almost as bad for your children - at least they will be able to point to their biological mother as an obvious reason for their troubles. I suppose an outside force is easier to reconcile than your internal force.


  • Name: Key
    Date posted: 2008-12-31 1:52 PM
    Hometown: Washington, DC

    Comment:

    Thomas & Nancy without hurting feels "In the beginning God created male and female. If God wanted you to be a male child and you had a sex change, would he not also have you change your internal parts as well? I saw the story on Oprah i said to myself wow, its a miracle then i found out you still had a female reproductive system which lets me know that you are still Female, and trying to to fool the WORLD into thinking that a man can have a baby. God did not intend on men having babies. Did you ever thing of adobtion? Then i thought how could he have a menstral cycle being male? hum... Mr. Beatie, no one knows but you and God. Yes we all fall short of the glory of God that is why we repent daily, i am no judge and i love you your wife and daughter just the same! my prayer for 2009 is that God bless you and your family always.


  • Name: wendy
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 10:14 PM
    Hometown: doncaster south yorkshire

    Comment:

    i watched a documentary about your pregnancy last night and i must say how moved i was, i think it is amazing what you have done. I was disgusted with how some people reacted, it was totally un called for, but we all have our own opinions i guess sad that it is at times. Your little baby is amazing a beautiful little girl, i hope all goes well in your next pregnancy and hope your little family will be happy and healthy good luck with the next pregnancy.


  • Name: Michele
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 7:50 PM
    Hometown: Düsseldorf

    Comment:

    I watched the programme about Thomas Beatie and his wife Nancy yesterday. Like most people, I was incredibly touched by their story. That's how I came to be on this page. I wanted to find a way to contact Thomas and Nancy to tell them how lovely I thought it was and how happy I am for them. Unfortunately I came across a lot of really negative and hatefilled comments. Now I'm asking myself 2 questions: Why is it that the people who are against this are always bringing God into it? And if they are such believers, shouldn't they be better Christians? I was always under the impression that good Christians should be accepting of all people. I'm afraid, this page shows quite the opposite. Instead of applauding Thomas and Nancy for their bravery and the love they show each other and their lucky little girl, they are being attacked by so called Chistians. I hope they all go to confession on a regular basis, because I'm sure that ridiculing and name calling are sins!


  • Name: Pam
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 9:58 AM
    Hometown: Gaborone ,Botswana

    Comment:

    congrats! i am so happy for them and they have my support all the way,if whatever they do is legal.they wanted biological children,they have evry right to have them.to all the people judging this couple,what do you want them to do?you want them to kidnap children?please leave them alone!why are you bothering them with what they choose to do with their lives? as long as it makes Thomas and nancy happy,i dont see why people should be making a big fuss out of it.get a life and leave thomas and nancy alone!they deserve to be happy, unlike the negative low-lives out there who cannot mind their own business! To thomas and his wife, if you feel like having ten more children,go ahead and forget about these miserable people who are saying negative things about you guys....


  • Name: Connie
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 6:30 AM
    Hometown: Weymouth, England

    Comment:

    I agree with all the positive comments here. I watched a positive documentary on "The Pregant Man" last night, and was quite moved by what i heard. All the rumors i had previously heard were obviously untrue, and it is clear that Thomas and Nancy are no different to any other parents, and will be as good as any others. I may be just sixteen, but i have a strong opinion on individualism. To the people who are against Thomas and Nancy's decision, i ask you, at what point does being different stop being acceptable? What right do these people have to question this family and view their ignorant comments online, in videos or however else they do. I say Well done to Thomas and Nancy and baby Susan, you deserve the right to be happy more than ignorant, one minded idiots who have nothing better to do than cause you greif. Hope it goes well, Connie JT xxxx


  • Name: Kenneth Nshiom
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 5:55 AM
    Hometown: Bafoussam, Cameroon

    Comment:

    Incredible, what a brave, bold and courageous couple in the face of all these criticism, maltreatment and stigma. Thomas, "you are really a man" How were you feeding your baby? Well, God is in control of all things. You are expecting your second child june 12, how is Susan, your first child doing? Best Wishes, Kenneth.


  • Name: colin
    Date posted: 2008-12-29 7:57 PM
    Hometown: london

    Comment:

    i love to watch such programs with great intrest as we develope as a human race to involve to the point tha one in we can truely have peace and understanding i have read the comments of support and browsed over the views of the narrow minded few who claim thomas is not a man "on that point i feel he is more of a man than most born that way he stood proud in front of the worlds media and said i have the right to live my life and provide for my family he has a loving wife and family" and the only time i feel sorry for them is that they will have to face the contast comments and finger pointing that should really be redirected to solve the worlds misunderstanding of true life to thomas and family i hope you find some peace on that long road ahead but stay strong for only you know in your heart what is right for you and your family


  • Name: Luc D'Anaud
    Date posted: 2008-12-29 6:11 PM
    Hometown: York, UK

    Comment:

    for all the people that consider him to be a freak... take a look at yourself and your life... how perfect are you? and why do you have the right to tell others what they can or cannot do. Congrats and good luck to the family, I hear they are expecting their 2nd child. Hope everything goes well.


  • Name: Patrice
    Date posted: 2008-12-29 5:58 PM
    Hometown: Perth, Australia

    Comment:

    Just wanted to show my support for Thomas and his family. You are very brave and I applaud your decision to have a child in the face of such controversy. Well done and all the best


  • Name: Samantha
    Date posted: 2008-12-29 11:53 AM
    Hometown: New York

    Comment:

    To all the people who think that the Beatie's children will grow up to have mental or emotional trauma: YOU are the kind of people who might cause that trauma. Thomas and Nancy are obviously loving, responsible parents. IF (God forbid) their children have issues later on- which is unlikely given how much their parents care for them- it will be because of people like you who cannot accept that they are part of a normal family. Saying that transgender people shouldn't have children because their kids might be teased is like saying minorities shouldn't have children because our racist society will make their lives difficult. We should work on changing society so that people are accepted for who they are, rather than discouraging people from having children because we think they might have problems along the way. EVERYONE has obstacles in their life, but with a supportive family those obstacles can be overcome. Best of luck to Thomas and Nancy and their beautiful children.


  • Name: Jamie
    Date posted: 2008-12-27 10:40 AM
    Hometown: Birmingham, Al

    Comment:

    I am watching the documentary on Thomas and his wife - I am overwhelmed with what gentle and loving people they are. I am really excited for their daughter. Though I am quite conservative and live in the heart of Dixie, I am also very human, and I am proud to know that this child will have such loving and kind parents. I am proud that Thomas and Nancy live in my country and can contribute to the humanity we all live amongst. I wish this family all the best.


  • Name: rebecca
    Date posted: 2008-12-27 1:47 AM
    Hometown: dupont, washington

    Comment:

    i think that i stood looking at Legos on Christmas Eve next to Thomas Beatie in a Wal-Mart in Washington State - and I wanted to apologize to him (if that was him) if i seemed awkward. i was torn between wanting to congratulate him on his lovely family and wanting to just let him shop for last minute Christmas gifts without being bothered. let me take the opportunity now to say how much i respect a couple who loves each other so much they want to devote themselves to raising children. i don't care what chromosomes a person is born with - genetics is not the only thing that influences who a person is. i had a difficult pregnancy and my husband told me many times that if he could carry our next baby he would. thomas beatie, you are a decent man and a loving husband. good luck with everything. please don't listen to the negative things people say. enjoy being a daddy!


  • Name: Naji
    Date posted: 2008-12-24 7:42 PM
    Hometown: San Diego

    Comment:

    I just want to say that I am happy for Thomas, Nancy, and Susan, and I hope this second pregnancy is old news to people and they move on. There is no news story here. This is a person with a uterus using it. This is a family having another baby. These children will have a lot going for them that so many children do not have, these children will have two loving parents. The only thing here that deserves time in the media is the atrocious behavior of the doctors and other "professionals" that denied these people care. I pray that, by the time Susan and her brother or sister are grown, this country will have matured enough that their family dynamic isn't all that dynamic afterall, and that they will just be normal people, like the rest of us. Selfishness is not living as one wishes to live, it is asking others to live as one wishes to live. --- Oscar Wilde


  • Name: Aimen
    Date posted: 2008-12-24 12:06 AM
    Hometown: Benghazi

    Comment:

    I just want to ask you that what is your baby called you? Is she agreed with you about your decision? Also, if you are right, why did God create two sexes ( female and male), two electricity charges, or two ends of a magnet (positive and negative)? And, can we keep contacting the same signs easily? I just want to know, because the angels have had only one kind that neither male nor female, so that are you angel?


  • Name: Corrine
    Date posted: 2008-12-23 11:45 PM
    Hometown: New Jersey

    Comment:

    I am a 48 year old woman with 4 adult children and 5 (going on 6) grandchildren. I made it a point to raise my children to be loving, accepting, open-minded adults. I am sorry the world STILL in this day and age has small, narrow-minded people in it. The hate that still exists, the racism, etc. is completely heartbreaking. Love is love, and THAT is beautiful. God bless Thomas, Nancy and their family. May He help them through this and protect them from the closed-minded judgemental people who want to tear them down.


  • Name: Stacey
    Date posted: 2008-12-22 11:17 AM
    Hometown: Glens Falls, NY

    Comment:

    Hopefully, someone can help me out or perhaps Thomas will read this and can answer these questions. I know that he was rejected by nine doctors before he gained access to a sperm bank. Was it hard to find a gyn/ob to see him through his pregnancy and deliver the baby? And I would like to know if he was treated with respect and recognized as a man? I cannot find answers to these questions and have read just about every article. Help me please.


  • Name: Stacey
    Date posted: 2008-12-22 11:16 AM
    Hometown: Glens Falls, NY

    Comment:

    I am writing a report for my Ethics class that is due on the 26th in support of Thomas' decision to give birth. I find him to be an incredible and brave MAN and I am appalled how he and his wife were rejected by medical professionals. Shame on them. That comment, "someone like him" is unprofessional and the hospital acted in an unethical manner. The medical profession is suppose to treat their patients with respect. They violated their work ethics and should have left their personal beliefs at home. If you cannot separate your work ethics from your personal ethics, then don't bother getting involved in the medical profession. Thomas and Nancy rock.


  • Name: Ellen
    Date posted: 2008-12-21 10:15 PM
    Hometown: Liverpool

    Comment:

    i just wana say congratulations i have also just watched a programme on more 4 an i think that Thomas and his wife should be very proud of the life he has created. People just need to learn to live and let live and let them get on with it. Im sure they will be excellent parents which is better than some people do for their children. Good luck with baby number 2 x


  • Name: S Bright
    Date posted: 2008-12-21 6:18 PM
    Hometown: Exeter

    Comment:

    I watched your programme this evening on More 4 and just wanted to say congratulations. My Husband and I have been trying to get pregnant for 3 years now with no success and are going down the route of treatment. I asked my husband would you carry a baby for us if you could. He replied yes without even thinking about it. I hope that Nancy and Thomas get to read this at some point and I want to just wish them all the happiness in the would and the best of luck with baby no 2. Congratulations and enjoy it. You appear to be two loving and amazing people, ignore the biggots and faciasts of this sad world and enjoy your babies!!


  • Name: Danielle
    Date posted: 2008-12-20 7:22 PM
    Hometown: England

    Comment:

    I would just like to say congrats to the happy parents, I know how happy I was when I had my little girl. I really hope everything goes well in your lives and in the life of your beautiful Daughter. Despite what some other people think and say your little girl was brought into the world with just as much love as any other and so will any other children you may decide to have. People who say nasty things about others whether because of colour, religion, or sexual orientation obviously do not understand what they are talking about. I think you were both very brave even considering having a child, I know I would be if I was in the same situation, but you have had to be even braver to put up with the harsh comments and even threats that have been made towards you. Well done and congrats again x


  • Name: Jessica W
    Date posted: 2008-12-17 4:39 PM
    Hometown: Stockholm

    Comment:

    Hello and CONGRATULATIONS to your cute daughter! I want to be honest with you, at first I thought like most of the people seems to think - that you biologically is a woman and that it's was weird. But like I heard you say with your own words in an documentary on TV - you are a legal man (don't know if I'm using the right term). You just wanted a family to love and hold just like (almost) everybody else. To get to my point - You are a role model to people out there in the same situation like yourself. You are an, if I may use the word: "Cool" man. I now, compared to how I first felt about you, admire your strenght, your courage, your love and your patience. And I think it's horrible how people can send you threatening videos and letters, and follow your every step and hunt you and your family. I vote for you as an father, and I send you my best wishes for a loving, caring, healty, long happy life together with your daugther and wife. /Jessica from Stockholm, Sweden


  • Name: Eddie
    Date posted: 2008-12-15 2:42 PM
    Hometown: Memphis, tn

    Comment:

    "He is a she." Sorry but the DNA says so. SHE still has XX. That means she is a female no matter how you look at it. It doesn't matter how one manipulates the physical appearance. It doesn't really matter to me what they do except I think that it is ridiculous that she gets officially labeled a male and the couple gets all of the government entitlements for a married couple. Your DNA determines sex, not appearance. If a sex change, which is still appearance, determines status, then all cross dressers should be labeled legally as they choose and be able to marry.


  • Name: R. P.
    Date posted: 2008-12-15 5:05 AM
    Hometown: Sacramento

    Comment:

    A transsexual is someone who believes they are the gender opposite the one they were born with. Thomas is, and identifies as, a man, despite his female sex organs. So no, it's not just a woman with her breasts removed. He is in the psychological mindset that he is a man, and has made the appropriate changes to his body to reflect that, except he hasn't gone through surgery to modify his sexual organs. This could be due to money or health concerns, as well as personal preference as the process of creating a functional penis from a vagina is not entirely advanced and some may want to wait until the process is more polished. He's a man, and the fact that he has chosen not to have surgery for whatever reason does not take away that right. Nor does the fact that he's chosen to bring a new life into his family due to his wife being unable to do so. I wish him the best.


  • Name: Andrea
    Date posted: 2008-12-14 10:02 PM
    Hometown: Lexington

    Comment:

    I have nothing against people that have a sex change op. No biggie. However, all the hype over this is insane. He/she has a vagina and all the organs needed to have a child. Big deal. I have had two children myself, I know it's the single greatest joy in the world. But isn't this still a woman that had her breasts removed?


  • Name: Samantha
    Date posted: 2008-12-14 10:48 AM
    Hometown: Dundee Scotland

    Comment:

    I must say this show moved me to tears, as someone who knows the pain and heartbreak of having difficulty concieving, I applaud your bravery and determination. I honestly believe that if two people are in a loving, lasting relationship then no one has any right whatsoever to judge them or their actions. As for people saying its immoral and its confusing when they have to explain this to their kids, its not the dark ages!! take the time as a parent to explain that everyone is different!! also they should ask themselves if they are so high on morals how morally do they live their own lives? im willing to bet none of them follow the bible etc to the letter.. most probably pick and chose which to adhere to when it suits them. People should keep their negative comments to themselves.. i wish you both love and congradulations x


  • Name: Vai Embry
    Date posted: 2008-12-14 3:02 AM
    Hometown: Singapore

    Comment:

    I just guess everyone should just be happy for them as a new born child is coming.. Does matter is the dad is a FTM... I give all the support to Beatie and his wife cos of the courage they had to tell his story to the world.........


  • Name: Renelyn Tabiliran
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 8:11 PM
    Hometown: philippines,Dipolog City

    Comment:

    but u know thats is for a sin sa ginagawa ni thomas,, because he changed the creation of God, kung anu siya,, he didn't contented of who he was,,she is a girl before, diba? But God know everything....


  • Name: Amie
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 6:39 PM
    Hometown: England

    Comment:

    Everyone that says "Omg your not a man blah blah" - HE IS A MAN BECAUSE BEING FTM MEANS YOU FEEL MALE, DESPITE BEING BORN INTO A FEMALE BODY. Why would anyone in their right mind have top surgery and take testosterone is they didnt feel 100% like they were a man?! And just because he chose to have the baby, doesnt make him less of a man either - he sees himself as a baby carrier, and he still feels positive and secure about his gender as male. His wife would obv carry a child if she could, but she cant, so why shouldnt Thomas?! They're not hurting anyone, they are loving parents who will bring their child up wonderfully, more than can be said for some stereotypical "normal" families who abuse and mistreat their child! Love is love and happy parents are hard to come by in this world, in the week of baby P I dont know HOW people can direct their anger at these wonderful people!!! LOVE AND SUPPORT FOR THOMAS AND NANCY!


  • Name: mrs english
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 5:34 PM
    Hometown: middlesbrough

    Comment:

    I just wanted to wish thomas and nancy and their soon to be 2 children all the very best of luck anyone who is a parent knows that raising children is no easy task never mind all the additional stuff they have been through. There are so many neglected children in the world we should be condemning the parents of those not a loving couple who want to be able to have and raise a family of their own. I think they are both very brave people and i send them all our best wishes from the uk xxx


  • Name: Natasha
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 4:11 PM
    Hometown: London

    Comment:

    I watched the documentary and can't believe how narrow minded and nasty people can be! It's so obvious how much Thomas and Nancy love each other and How much that beautiful baby girl is loved and wanted. If only we could say the same about some children born into "normal" families. Good luck to them for the next baby and the future.


  • Name: nina
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 9:41 AM
    Hometown: Preston

    Comment:

    when i watched the programme all i saw were two loving people that appeared genuinely kind hearted with a beautiful and healthy liitle girl. For all the nasty comments there are as many supportive ones. Many children have a terrible upbringing with the so called 'traditional family' .Peoples gender choices dont make bad people or parents. Wish you well


  • Name: Corri Lee
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 8:41 AM
    Hometown: WEst Midlands, UK

    Comment:

    I also saw the UK documentary last night and I applaud what you're doing. If only male pregnancy was an option for men who have not had to go through the nightmare of surgically adjusting their body and struggling to seek acceptance from loved ones, the problem of some couples not being able to conceive would be less of a heartbreaking problem all over the world. Society is way too eager to blow these things out of proportion when the fact of it is what woman wouldn't prefer their significant others to go through the excruciating 'miracle' of childbirth?


  • Name: VANESSA HOLMES
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 6:00 AM
    Hometown: TODMORDEN ENGLAND

    Comment:

    I WATCHED THE PROGRAM ABOUT THOMAS AND NANCY IN THE UK LAST NIGHT ND I JUST WANT TO GIVE MY FULL SUPPORT AND GIVE MY BEST WISHES TO THE FAMILY WHAT THEY HAVE DONE IS THE MOST NATURAL THING IN THE WORLD AND THEY ARE GOING TO BE FABULOUS PARENTS TO THE BABY AND THE BABY THEY ARE EXPECTING! IT REALLY ANGERED ME HOW SOME PEOPLE CAN BE SO NARROW MINDED AND NASTY TOWARDS THEM! IA AM A MOTHER OF4 MYSELF AND KNOW WHAT ITS LIKE TO WANT A CHILD THAT BAD YOU WOULD DO ANYTHING TO GET THAT CHILD ! TO ME THOMAS AND NANCY ARE A NORMAL COUPLE LIVING A NORMAL LIFE AND SHOULD BE LEFT ALONE TO BRING THEIR CHILDREN UP JUST LIKE EVERYONE ELSE AND PEOPLE SHOULD STOP BEING SO NASTY AND LEAVE THEM ALONE!!!! SO ALL MY LOVE AND BEST WISHES TO THOAMS AND NANCY AND BABY SUZANNE AND I HOPE THEM ALL THE BEST FOR THE FUTURE XXXXXX VANESSA HOLMES UK XXXXXXX


  • Name: Sarah Johnson
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 4:56 AM
    Hometown: Northampton, England

    Comment:

    Just watched the doccumentary about Thomas and Nancy in the UK. I really don't see a problem - a loving couple having a child, why is perceived gender such a problem for some people? Gender does not dictate whether a person can be a good parent or love their child. I am horrified at the outpouring of hate against two decent individuals - the ignorant comments that this child may come to some sort of emotional harm based on other peoples tainted perceptions shocked me. Thank goodness Susan will grow up in a loving home - enough children from what the public would view as 'normal' never have that chance. Happy Christmas from me and my 5 month old son. x


  • Name: ANITA
    Date posted: 2008-12-11 8:18 PM
    Hometown: PAOLI

    Comment:

    WELL I GUESS I CAN UNDERSTAND A WOMAN GETTINSEX CHANGE TO BECOME A MAN THEN GIVING BIRTH WIERD THINGS HAPPEN BUT WHEN I SAW YOUR SHOW AND YOU SAID THAT YOU FELT LIKE THE MAN WITH A TUMOR.THAT PISSED ME OFF ITS A TUMOR GIVE ME A BREAK YOU KNOW THERE R PPL OUT HERE THAT HAVE TUMORS LIKE ME AND MY 15YR OLD IT IS CALLED NEUROFIBROMATOSIS AND WE HAVE TUMORS THAT CAUSE PAIN ALL THE TIME YOU NEED TO GROW UP AND NOT MAKE FUN OF US WHO HAVE TUMORS LIKE THAT WE CAN NOT HELP IT YOU WANT PPL TO ACCEPT YOU THEN STOP MAKING FUN OF US


  • Name: Jorunn Vea
    Date posted: 2008-12-11 3:37 PM
    Hometown: Svingvoll

    Comment:

    My God... We're surprised of all the negative comments.. Why can't people see you are a family foremost? You have acchieved somthing unexpected.. Enjoy it! And give a dam about those who have a different oppinion! We wish you all the happiness in the world. Now and in the future. Merry Christmas:o) Love from Ida and Jorunn (Mother and daughter) from Norway!


  • Name: louella belle
    Date posted: 2008-12-10 1:41 AM
    Hometown: koronadal

    Comment:

    love is love, nothing you could say or do could change that. those people who are so judgmental are just idiots. maybe you people haven't fallen in love yet. once you dont understand something, you become afraid, and once you become afraid you tend to destroy it. everybody has a chance to be happy in life. those who are too shallow and dumb to understand the idea of building a family, its not just about a man and a woman, Family is more than that, the most important component of a family is LOVE. This two people here loves eachother, and the child that will be born to them will be brought up in love too. thats what really counts. gender is just an excuse. deal with it. thats reality. nosy people who are too damn hypocrite to recognize our existence are just playing stupid, face us! we are not a virus, I dont like the reaction of people to this couple, even the doctors are just cruel an unjust. hell! are you critiques perfect?!


  • Name: jane
    Date posted: 2008-12-08 10:55 AM
    Hometown: Witchita,Kansas

    Comment:

    mr.lee or should I say ms.lee you should of had a baby befor you removed your breast surgically. that poor and soon to be hungry baby. you should've thought about how this effect this child's life.


  • Name: ashlee
    Date posted: 2008-12-05 5:42 PM
    Hometown: roswell

    Comment:

    you two are so sick. i truelly believe that the child is in for a very rough life, how could you possible want that for any child. i also believe being in the public eye is going to do alot of damage. being a man and being legally male are to very diffrent things.i don't think you thought this threw.


  • Name: Renaye K. James
    Date posted: 2008-12-05 3:05 AM
    Hometown: Atlanta, GA

    Comment:

    The only thing that makes this news is how this woman's perversion and subsequent demand for public acceptance is creating a subtle change in what society considers normal versus abnormal. The success of these two women to make like man and wife to the point that people are accepting of or complacent about it will give others the go ahead to create similar lifestyles. The problem is that where man's will conflicts with God's, HELL will break loose and it promises not to be pretty, cute, cuddly or loving... Larry King called it a "curse" for someone to feel like a man inside (mentally and emotionally) but be a woman outside (physically). According to Romans 1:18-32, looks like Larry was right on the money!


  • Name: Raven Taylor
    Date posted: 2008-12-05 2:32 AM
    Hometown: Hartford, CT

    Comment:

    Beatie still has to physically function like a woman in all other aspects except where breasts were removed and I suppose, what public restroom Beatie goes to. Beatie claims to have an enlarged clitoris that functions like a penis such that Beatie and Nancy have intercourse same as heterosexuals. Medical findings report that even w/hormone injections, as part of the female-to-male transition, the clitoris "never completely adapts to the masculinization of its owner, will never be able to ejaculate or urinate and is small in comparison to the genitalia of a natural born male." That said, there is NO SUCH THING nor will there ever be a pregnant man. Leave those seahorse books alone!


  • Name: Patty
    Date posted: 2008-12-04 4:51 PM
    Hometown: BC

    Comment:

    To Mirjana: "God" would be happy that this baby has two loving parents, regardless of gender. I'm a woman and my wife and I want to start a family. Love makes a family. I for one support Thomas Beatie's intelligent, well-thought out decision. I admire his and his wife's courage.


  • Name: mirjana
    Date posted: 2008-12-04 12:05 PM
    Hometown: Calgary,Alberta Canada

    Comment:

    I believe this world has become crazy....for a man to carry a child???Then why do we need women, man has replaced us in many ways...if these people believed in GOD they would have never done this.......


  • Name: Doug Gempel
    Date posted: 2008-12-02 11:32 PM
    Hometown: Columbus-Westerville-ohio

    Comment:

    Its not really politically coorect. The white stuff on top of chicken shit is still dung. The definition of male or man here is twisted, genetcally speaking this couple is two females.


  • Name: Gerti
    Date posted: 2008-11-30 8:17 PM
    Hometown: Michigan City, IN 46360

    Comment:

    What will happen is your daughter dates the donated sperm of the man who donated his sperm to her? Also, is going public a financial consideratin as all this is very expensive although it seems that you two love each other and last... is Nancy Bruce Jenner's former wife?


  • Name: Lisa
    Date posted: 2008-11-30 10:33 AM
    Hometown: Dover

    Comment:

    I just want to say what u did was wonderful and me and my fiance want to have a child but we wanted to know how much it cost cause ur one of the few that actually concieved a child we just wanna know how much this procidure costed.please send me an email thank you


  • Name: Rosy
    Date posted: 2008-11-26 1:29 PM
    Hometown: Denver

    Comment:

    I think that if every child were to have the good fortune to be as wanted and cherished as all of Thomas and Nancy's children will be, the world would be a far better place.


  • Name: Rachel
    Date posted: 2008-11-25 2:36 PM
    Hometown: Bowling Green

    Comment:

    My 4 year old saw the program on tv for a short moment and asked me how that man was pregnant. I had to tell him the truth that she was really a woman because that is what she is. I do not judge them in any way. I don't agree with it but I have to let my child know that he cannot have a baby when he grows up. I also told him that she just chooses to look like a man but is really a woman. This is very confusing to a child.


  • Name: reco
    Date posted: 2008-11-24 9:33 PM
    Hometown: little rock

    Comment:

    How I feel about this is god made people.No one is alike.What god has for him it is for the Lee is for Lee.Let Lee live this life and pray for the transgenders.You dont have to like what Lee's done.Who am i to say something bad about transgenderes.What I say dont live a lye let the child or children know.What happen because they will find out.God bless good bye...


  • Name: Wendy
    Date posted: 2008-11-24 9:58 AM
    Hometown: Manitowoc, WI

    Comment:

    This should not be creating the media frenzy that it is. I think it's drawn attention because things were unclear about how Thomas could be a "man" yet still have female reproductive organs. If you're trying to learn something then that is what you should be learning about, not why - that's not your business. Open your minds to learn, not judge. I definitely think the world is curious and I think the focus should be on the facts about being transgender. Too many people think THEIR opinion and views are important to others, well wake up & quit trying to push those opinions and views on everyone else.


  • Name: Katt
    Date posted: 2008-11-24 1:51 AM
    Hometown: Martinez

    Comment:

    BRAVO!!! Choosing to having a family is a blessing, not a right that someone must fight for! I wish Thomas, Nancy, & their new daughter all the best in the universe!


  • Name: Mallorie
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 10:03 PM
    Hometown: in Boise, ID

    Comment:

    It's extremely sad that in some states assisted suicide is legal and much more accepted than those who transition, let alone a transgendered person giving birth to a baby. Transgenders are some of the most honest people in the world. They are true to who they are, even when faced with violence and ridicule. Thomas and Nancy Beatie are amazing people and there shouldn't be a problem with a husband and wife raising a child. My best wishes go out to them. Unfortunately what those don't understand they fear, and fear turns to anger.


  • Name: Verona and Sean
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 9:51 PM
    Hometown: Charleston, SC

    Comment:

    first i would like to say congrats on your baby girl. And yes, there sure do seem to be a lot of "this is wrong" posts here... As I see it Thomas Beatie is a man who loves his wife, and like her, wants a family. Devotion like this is incredible. The only thing I see as being "wrong" in this picture is the worlds fascintation with how f'd up this is. A baby is a baby, and a family a family. The Beaties will be great parents and it is a shame that they cannot enjoy parenthood without ridicule. Everyone needs to get over it. they are not carrying this child. Thomas is. Most of you have never even met them. So to the beaties, stay strong, and congrats!


  • Name: Amanda
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 9:39 AM
    Hometown: Hanover PA

    Comment:

    I watched your story on t.v the other night. And also heard that you are expecting again! so soon after the last baby. I have a 10 week old baby and I can not even think about doing all that again so soon. But any way at frist I felt conflicted about you story. But after I saw your wonderful baby come into to world. I knew the kind of love you were feeling for that baby. I have done it twice and no matter how you are bringing your children into the world, Or if you call your self a male or a female. you are still bringing a percious life into this world. That is something wonderfull no matter how it is done. We are all gods childeren no matter how we are or who we are. He loves us all no matter what. That is onething those of you who say such crule things to Thomas and Nancy should rember. also " do not judge least you be judged". Thomas and Nancy I wish all the love and luck in the world.


  • Name: Airdre Knox
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 4:05 AM
    Hometown: Melbourne, Australia

    Comment:

    I have just watched your interview with Diane Sawyer and I think you're a very special couple with a wonderful view of life, and I congratulate you on your new baby (and the way your handled the interview)! I admire your strength and love for life, and for one another, and I wish you all the best for the future. It's true Thomas, you were a beautiful girl - why this matters I don't know... but now you're a much more beautiful man.


  • Name: rulit2
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 1:47 AM
    Hometown: peoria

    Comment:

    i think alot of you are missing the point here .... what they wanna do behing closed doors is nobodys business but theirs but its not about them they are bringing a life into this world and its about that child. he/she has been taking large quantities of hormones for a very long time which has a good chance of adversly affecting the baby's development/health not to mention that children can be very cruel..... can you imagine the hell this child will go through in school being teased? in my opinion its selfish of them to do it this way why not adopt and avoid the chance of having a deformed child or a child that will be psychologically tormented their entire life?


  • Name: DLJ Cromatie
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 7:35 PM
    Hometown: Youngstown

    Comment:

    I am no crazy person but i was really interested in this story and would love it if you could let the real Thomas Beatie contact me. I am a female that wants to do the same surgery to become a man and want to pick his brain and talk to someone who has been there and knows what i am in for I really would like to talk to him because i have so many questions about the whole process. THANKS!


  • Name: Sierra
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 5:45 PM
    Hometown: Denham Springs LA

    Comment:

    i think all u wanna be christians need to get a life! who gave any of u the right to judge? U do know the bible says judging other is wrong an also that u cannot be both hot an cold . meaning u cannot be in church being a holy rolie then be on here talkin about how wrong this family is an making threats . grow up there not hurting u there not doing anything wrong TO U.geez.


  • Name: Oson
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 12:39 PM
    Hometown: Darien, Georgia

    Comment:

    Also you should think about the mental state of the babies you are producing. When they are of age they will have some sort of complex or mental disorder because of you. In my opinion you are selfish and the people who buy into you being a man having a baby are no better, because they are making money off of you. You are now a circus freak for the world and the only one you will have to blame is yourself. Last but not least what you do is your business, you should have never broadcasted it to the world. Your children will suffer for this and they will blame you and hate you.


  • Name: Damian D. Williams (Oson)
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 12:38 PM
    Hometown: Darien, Georgia

    Comment:

    Truth be told Thomas or Tracy you are still a woman because what makes you A woman is the fact that you still have a womb. Men and woman are not merely determined by there genital organs but by the way they reproduce. Man with a womb "Womb-man". So you are robbing the media and the book of world records because you having a baby has been being done since Eve. If you really want to do something different change your inside and not your outside. Then have a baby through your penis.


  • Name: Carrie
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 12:20 PM
    Hometown: Bethlehem, PA

    Comment:

    Congratulations on the birth of your beautiful daughter!


  • Name: Shaye
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 11:54 AM
    Hometown: Augusta

    Comment:

    I am watching your story on tv right no. I just wanted to say congratulations to both of you. It shouldn't matter if you are male or female, gay or straight. You two are clearly in love and that is a beautiful thing. Any child who is born to two loving, supportive parents is lucky. And congratulations on your new pregnancy too.


  • Name: Valeria
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 10:19 AM
    Hometown: Madrid, London

    Comment:

    Hello Thomas and Nancy I just wanted to express my support. I find your openminded attitude moving and your courage highly admirable. You are proud of who you are and so you should be. I am an eterosexual woman, born woman, and I feel not at all shocked or outraged by your choice. I admire you as a couple as I admire Nancy's doughters maturity.


  • Name: Stacy
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 9:04 AM
    Hometown: Wisconsin

    Comment:

    I think its wrong! Because your a man on the outside and an women on the inside. So you are actually an gay couple but hiding in a man's body.., for example " A sheep in wolf's clothing" ..., Not there anything wrong with that to quote "Jerry Sienfeld".But who am I to judge. You don't have to answer to me.


  • Name: Elaine
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 8:12 PM
    Hometown: Ohio

    Comment:

    Hi Thomas and Nancy I first heard about your story when you were on Oprah. I must admit I was a bit torn when I heard the details of your story, but after watching your show on Discovery, I decided you are a happy, loving family, and Susan is a very lucky little girl. I was happy for you when I learned you are expecting a new baby, and wish you a good pregnancy, safe delivery, and another beautiful, happy child for your family.


  • Name: Tina
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 2:27 PM
    Hometown: Ohio

    Comment:

    Thomas and Nancy, I watched your story on Oprah and Discovery. You are a warm,happy, loving family. Every child deserves to be loved by a family, and that is what you are giving Susan and her new little brother or sister. I'm so sorry for all the hate and ignorance being directed toward you. All you want is to have a baby, and be a family. It's no one else's business. Your daughter is lucky to be born into a stable, loving family. Keep your chins up and know that there are many people out there who support you, and send love and blessings your way. Stay happy, and many congratulations!


  • Name: Lisa
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 2:13 PM
    Hometown: Hampton

    Comment:

    Ummm.... this is crazy. Really crazy. The WHOLE thing.


  • Name: COURTNEY
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 1:52 PM
    Hometown: MISSISSIPPI

    Comment:

    EVERYONE IN THE WORLD NEEDS TO PRAY FOR YOU PEOPLE IF YOU ONLY KNEW HOW IT FEELS TO BE ABLE TO BE HAPPY WITH WHAT GOD HAS GIVEN AND HOW IT FEELS TO GO HOME TO YOUR SPOUSE THATS A REAL MAN INSIDE AND OUT AND MAKE LOVE AND IT GENIUNE AND NATURAL THE OTHER GIRL IN THE RELATIONSHIP NEEDS TO RUN AWAY AS FAR AS POSSIBLE AND FIND A REAL MAN THAT WILL TAKE CARE OF HER LIKE A REAL MAN CAN


  • Name: courtney
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 1:35 PM
    Hometown: mississippi

    Comment:

    this is not really as amazing as you all have everyone thinking technically your still a woman considering you have all of our organs all you have is a penis a fake penis at that


  • Name: Elisabeth
    Date posted: 2008-11-20 10:59 PM
    Hometown: Harrisonburg, VA, USA

    Comment:

    Congratulations, Thomas and Nancy! Don't be bothered by all the poor ignorant souls who try to bring you down. You are both incredibly brave. Good luck with everything and stay strong!


  • Name: joe
    Date posted: 2008-11-20 1:48 PM
    Hometown: wallew

    Comment:

    this is bullshit. this woman is confused.


  • Name: sharon yenom
    Date posted: 2008-11-20 11:48 AM
    Hometown: toronto

    Comment:

    this is the most ridiculous thing ever, it is virtually impossible for a male to get pregnant , maybe in the future centuries but currently it sounds pretty fiction and its jsut about a couple of people trying to get some attention from society, sorry buddy, not very convincing and for those who do belive in this tale cleary is getting sucked into ur act and has messed up perception :)


  • Name: sam
    Date posted: 2008-11-20 1:53 AM
    Hometown: birmingham

    Comment:

    they are going to burn in hell and if you think that this is ok then you are messed up too. these are the end times and nothing surprise me anymore all of this is against what god says about this , and iam not surprise to hear you say this mimm.keyes anybody thats not saved would think that way .


  • Name: Reece
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:30 PM
    Hometown: Portland, OR

    Comment:

    Thomas, I think you're at the point in your life where you can finally be comfortable with yourself and your image. You have no reason to be insecure because you choose to live such an open lifestyle. Forget the negative comments, because this is your life, and everyone is free in the pursuit of happiness. The only thing that can be implied of your daughter is that she will be a strong willed person. I thank you for your courage to release your story to the media. Your life has changed the world forever. I hope one day we can look back on this and think, "wow, I can't believe people were so hateful."


  • Name: Claudia
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:29 PM
    Hometown: Houston ,TX

    Comment:

    A baby is a blessing and as longs as that baby is gonna have two loving parents it doesn't matter who they are. Nancy and Thomas congrats on the baby and i wish you the best of luck .


  • Name: kaycflores
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:28 PM
    Hometown: Texas

    Comment:

    I just wanted to say congrats on Susan and I wish you two all the best of luck with the second child. I am currently expecting my second and I believe as long as you two are in this together and love one another that is all you guys need. It doesn't matter to me who carries the child as long as both of you support one another. Again, I just wanted to congratulate you two and I wish all the best of luck to you guys.


  • Name: Becca
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:28 PM
    Hometown: kansas City, MO

    Comment:

    I am watching your story on the discovery health channel now and I just want to say how courageous you both are. I am thrilled that you are able to have a family and it is unfortunate that others cannot see it in this way. I agree with you "I am embarrassed to be a human" because of how hateful we can be. As a social work student I actually wrote a paper on your story and the discrimination you face. I admire you both and I only wish you happiness and love.


  • Name: Mark Dawson
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:14 PM
    Hometown: Muncie Ind.

    Comment:

    Congrats on your birthing and enjoy the family in Love... but born a woman always a woman and lets drop the false assertions of you being A Man Technicalities are things not to be over looked. Lets se a man with a real Penis have one who has both sets of plumbing.


  • Name: chantell
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 7:13 PM
    Hometown: mississippi

    Comment:

    when is the baby due or did you have the baby already if do plese tell us becuse we whont to know ok. plese tell us on tv what there names are.


  • Name: Alicia Keys
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 5:21 PM
    Hometown: New York

    Comment:

    Hey,l this is Alicia Keys. Yes, this is me. If you ask for any sort of evidence you won't get any because all that matters is I know who I am. Ok, this is a miracle this isn't as popular news to most people. But, this will make History, he is the first man ever to have a baby. We should be blessed to be seeing this.


  • Name: missey
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 5:03 PM
    Hometown: 1123 creast haven trail

    Comment:

    hey tomes my name is missey i like your wife and your baby she is so cute like if you need a baby sitter plese email me .i heard you are going to have another baby if do girl or boy and how are you going to have your baby plese tell how to opra ok thanks missey your firend missey.


  • Name: Dana Smith
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 4:51 PM
    Hometown: Harlem, New York City

    Comment:

    It's not like he wanted to have a baby. It's weird, but it gives a man a feeling what a lot women get. I think he's going to get a sea section, because well he's a guy. And the only person to blame is God, and everything he does is for a reason.


  • Name: missy
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 4:39 PM
    Hometown: 1123 creast haven trail

    Comment:

    hi my name is cassie from me and you. iav seen your out come you are so cool can you have five babys to like a human person if can send me a letter ok .but what is your babys names plese tell me ok i will be looking ford meeting you in person . love cassie and lil wane


  • Name: Maria
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 2:15 PM
    Hometown: Seattle

    Comment:

    First off let me say that what I think you two are doing is a beautiful thing, and I wish with all my heart all the world's happiness to you both and your beautiful children. I am so saddened by all the negative comments people have made. Please, people, open your minds and your hearts to this beautiful family. Who are we to judge other people? If you Christians are so religious like you say you are, then leave the judging to God. And God loves people who love others and do well for others, just like this wonderful family. All my blessings!


  • Name: Ariel
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 12:31 AM
    Hometown: Virigina

    Comment:

    i think its amazing that you are the first pregnant ( male/female) i was absolutly obessed with the whole it its pretty cool..and i have always wanted to be a OB/GYN and i would have loved to deliver your baby


  • Name: Faintly
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 12:14 AM
    Hometown: Portland

    Comment:

    Hope, you're a twit. Get a life.


  • Name: Layla
    Date posted: 2008-11-18 11:42 PM
    Hometown: Grover Beach, CA

    Comment:

    I think it's amazing and beautiful. :-)


  • Name: Tami
    Date posted: 2008-11-18 10:58 PM
    Hometown: Taylor, Michigan

    Comment:

    Thomas and Nancy, I want to say congradulations on your little girl. I think it is great what you guys are doing and I just wish everyone out there would open their minds and their hearts to you. I hope your family continues to grow because it is very obvious that you two really love one another. Again congradulations.


  • Name: Bonnie
    Date posted: 2008-11-18 10:46 PM
    Hometown: Northampton, Ma

    Comment:

    Thomas, the only thing that surprises me about your carrying a baby is that the pictures of you pregnant DON'T look surprising! On a completely different note, I (a straight woman divorced from a straight man) had an ectopic pregnancy and several miscarriages in all of our attempts to have the one baby we were finally able to have. So my heart completely goes out to you because of your ectopic, your experiences going on and off of hormones, and all of the emotional and physical difficulty I know you lived through. What a strong and loving man you must be. And more brave in the face of a judgmental world than I can even imagine. You announced your pregnancy with your second child on my birthday! I'm tickled for you, Nancy and Susan! What lucky babies to have such an intentional, devoted, loving family.


  • Name: marc
    Date posted: 2008-11-18 3:10 PM
    Hometown: moncton

    Comment:

    until this MAN can impregnate himself (with his own man-spirit), he is a WOMAN.


  • Name: Granny
    Date posted: 2008-11-17 11:34 PM
    Hometown: Menifee, CA

    Comment:

    Will you please tell me how a woman who has a double mastectomy and takes testosterone can get a real marriage license???????? I thought you had to be one man and one woman in most states? You say you get all the financial and legal federal benenfits. How exactly did you do that? You still have a vagina and all of your productive organs. Just how did the federal government recognize you as a man? We all need this information and this is written for purposes of gaining knowledge, not criticizing anyone.


  • Name: Hope
    Date posted: 2008-11-17 8:42 PM
    Hometown: Alabama

    Comment:

    I dont know what the big deal is about a woman giving birth. Women have been doing it since time began, hint Adam and Eve. I believe sick whack jobs who cant decide what gender they are have no business having kids. Despite your views on religion i believe a higher power decides what sex you are. Know wonder this world or shall i say country is going to hell when we praise such abominations as this. Lets just hope those two freaks dont decide thier child was born the WRONG sex and screw her up before she gets grown and can get away from those two nut and stay away from them, because she hates them for what they have done. And i promise she will hate them for it.


  • Name: Mark
    Date posted: 2008-11-17 4:32 PM
    Hometown: Houston

    Comment:

    Cause if you cant see the love that this person is doing for his spouse then maybe you need to take a look at it and maybe learn from it. Would u do something so similar Bruce if you had a wife that could not have a baby would you go over and beyond and find a way to have a child of your own. Or how about you Cheryl would you do that same if you had a husband. Or what about you Travis. I bet all three of you would not do the extreme to show your love to someone. Maybe you sending hurtful out to hurt someone is telling us that you dont care much for someone to be able to do this. I think personnal if i would be able to do this i would. No matter the obstacle i would do it. I congradualate you once more for what you are doing. ....... Thank you so much.....


  • Name: Mark
    Date posted: 2008-11-17 4:31 PM
    Hometown: Houston

    Comment:

    For those of you that dont see the point in what this MAN is trying to do then maybe you should do some research on the topics of love and of gender issues. This woman considers herself to be male mentally. So she has fixed her outter apperance to look like she feels. I congradulate him and his wife on everything they are doing. Straight people make it seems like gay couples are only out to hurt other people. My Straight bialogical mother was a major drug addict and when she bore me i was born a alcohol fetal baby. So straight people have the same faults that gay people do. Another thing Travis and Bruce and Cheryl if you dont like something then don't li