Homophobic Colorado Web Designer Returns to Trial Court After Supreme Court Win

Lawyers for Lorie Smith, the web designer who doesn’t want to serve same-sex couples, were back in court this week as Colorado prepares to implement the favorable ruling she received from the U.S. Supreme Court in June.

Smith, owner of 303 Creative, wants to offer wedding websites but says providing them to same-sex couples would violate her free speech rights, even though Colorado law bans discrimination based on sexual orientation. She objects to same-sex marriage because of her conservative Christian beliefs.

She sued in 2016 challenging the state’s antidiscrimination law, and after she lost at the federal district court and appeals court levels, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 303 Creative v. Elenis that she had the right to refuse to create messages with which she disagrees. The high court sent the case back to U.S. District Court in Colorado for the state to approve an order recognizing that right.

In the district court Tuesday, lawyers for Smith and the state said they would join in drafting an injunction saying Smith would not be punished under Colorado law. Chief Judge Philip A. Brimmer gave them until December 7 to do, Colorado Politics reports. If they can’t agree on the language, he said, each side can submit its version and he’ll come up with a final order.

Trending stories

JD Vance ruthlessly mocked after everyone in Greenland refused to welcome wife Usha Vance

Joe Biden has tied the record for most LGBTQ+ judges confirmed in federal courts

Where to stay in LGBTQ+ Ireland: Castles, domes and luxury retreats

The Charles is Pacific Grove's new LGBTQ+ hotel

Watch: In gay period romance 'Lilies Not For Me,' playful wrestling turns sensual (exclusive)

Gerald Garth is keeping people of color happy and healthy through trying times

Elon Musk uses burner accounts on X, doesn’t fact-check: report

Season 4 of The Switch on resilience & radical self-love returns this spring

How climate disasters hurt mental health in young people

Discover the power of Wellness in your life

Alan Cumming jumps for joy after major 'Avengers: Doomsday' casting news

Trump's orders prompt CDC to erase HIV resources

'Mid-Century Modern': Celebrate Linda Lavin's most iconic roles

All 6 rogue Mississippi cops got long prison sentences in 'Goon Squad' torture of 2 Black men

Discover why chic Costa Navarino is Europe's luxury getaway

​6 lesbian films coming we can't wait to see in 2025

Cowboys & Queens U.S. tour by Jane Hilton: A modern American dream

In 'Mid-Century Modern,' the 'gay Avengers' assemble for needed comic relief

Nathan Lee Graham wants 'Mid-Century Modern's queer viewers to 'lean into the joy'

France becomes world’s first country to enshrine abortion rights in constitution

SFAF's Dr. Tyler TerMeer says he'll continue to fight for health care for all

Matt Bomer, as a 'Mid-Century Modern' ditz, can finally 'experience queer joy'

Bob the Drag Queen shades Mistress Isabelle Brooks’ weight loss: 'Girl, you have to get new pads'

In 'Survival of the Thickest,' queer joy and activism are one and the same

From rock legends to Pride flags: Discover the vibrant LGBTQ+ scene in Asbury Park

• 0
• 1
• 2
• 3
• 4
• 5
• 6
• 7
• 8

When the case came back to the district court, it was initially assigned to Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney, the first out gay federal judge in Colorado. She recused herself, saying her impartiality might be questioned. Brimmer then took over the case.

Smith has not been in the wedding website business so far, so her refusal to create them for same-sex couples was a preemptive move. Her site says wedding websites are coming soon.

She was represented in her case by the Alliance Defending Freedom, which has represented many other anti-LGBTQ+ clients, including Colorado baker Jack Phillips, who was sued after he refused to create a custom wedding cake for a same-sex couple. The Colorado Civil Rights Commission found him in violation of state law, and he appealed all the way to the Supreme Court, which vacated the commission’s ruling against him in 2018, saying commissioners had shown insufficient respect for his religious beliefs.