The United States
isn't ready for man-on-man action, at least not on the
television. A study conducted by Los Angeles based
multicultural research firm New American Dimensions
found that an MTV Canada anti-marijuana ad featuring
two men kissing is too edgy for American viewers.
The commercial,
which aired for a short time on MTV Canada, features
three young men in a parked car, two in front and one in
back, smoking a bong of marijuana. The man in the
passenger seat, obviously stoned, passes the bong to
his friend in the backseat while remarking, "Whoa,
this stuff's really good." As the two men in front give each
other a wasted look, they get closer and then lock
into a deep, sensual kiss. The man in the back,
confused, asks "Aren't you guys...brothers?" A caption
then appears stating, "If you're high, just make sure you
don't drive."
The study finds
that two thirds of straight Canadians felt comfortable
with the kiss, while only half of straight Americans found
it acceptable. In fact, a quarter of straight
Americans described themselves as "very uncomfortable"
with the ad. Both American and Canadian gays felt
positively about LGBT-focused marketing, yet some found the
overt nature of the commercial inappropriate. Overall,
the response was lukewarm.
"Showing
gay people or a same-sex encounter in a mainstream
commercial can mean a lot to LGBT consumers, as long
as it is done tastefully," said David Morse,
president and CEO of New American Dimensions, in a press
release about the study.
"However,
showing too much realism can still alienate mainstream
consumers, particularly Americans. Canadians are clearly
more open-minded on the subject of LGBT marketing, but
even they appear to have a threshold. The kiss in this
commercial may have crossed it." (The
Advocate)