Alleged Extortion Plot Involves Gay Relationship With Major Leaguer

A man accused of an extortion plot against Minnesota Twins pitcher Carl Pavano says they had a sexual relationship while in high school in Connecticut.

Police in Southington, Conn., are investigating whether there is sufficient evidence that Christian Bedard sought compensation from Pavano's family in exchange for his silence about the relationship, the Hartford Courantreports. They searched Bedard's home last week and seized a laptop computer and a journal, but no charges have been filed.

The search warrant affidavit states that Michelle DeGennaro, Pavano's sister, says Bedard contacted her via Facebook in December. It summarizes the exchange by saying, "Bedard states Pavano is gay, and they had a relationship when they were growing up. Bedard said he has a book deal in place worth $1.2 million and that it can all go away if Pavano buys him a navy Range Rover with tan leather."

Bedard, however, says DeGennaro made the initial contact, "asking under what conditions would I not talk about my relationship with Carl," according to a statement he emailed the Associated Press. He says he replied asking for an apology for his treatment by Pavano when the relationship ended and made the comment about the Range Rover "in jest."

Bedard also says his friends and family knew about his sexual relationship with Pavano. DeGennaro says there was no such relationship, and Pavano, who is married with two children, has declined to comment to the press.

Bedard, whose mother, Elaine, is a prominent local politician, has been convicted of several crimes, including driving under the influence and third-degree burglary, according to the Courant. Pavano, a former New York Yankee, is beginning his third season with the Twins.