![Dnc96x390](https://www.advocate.com/media-library/dnc96x390.jpg?id=32714284&width=1200&height=876)
CONTACTStaffCAREER OPPORTUNITIESADVERTISE WITH USPRIVACY POLICYPRIVACY PREFERENCESTERMS OF USELEGAL NOTICE
© 2024 Pride Publishing Inc.
All Rights reserved
All Rights reserved
By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Private Policy and Terms of Use.
It's weathered
with age; its font is a bit vintage. But the message of the 1996 internal memo on the stakes of a presidential
reelection is strikingly current, even more than 15 years later:
"To abandon the President
who has delivered on the overwhelming majority of his commitment to gays and
lesbians to end discrimination, especially when the alternative is virtually
guaranteed to be a President who will rapidly turn back the clock on gay and
lesbian progress, would be a political mistake which would haunt gays and
lesbians for decades," wrote Brian Bond, former executive director of the
Democratic National Committee's Gay and Lesbian Leadership Council, in a
January 1996 memorandum to Democratic National Committee and White House
officials. Included is a compendium of administration accomplishments, from
endorsement of the still-pending Employment Non-Discrimination Act to
significant increases in public health spending on HIV/AIDS -- milestones
overshadowed in particular by one lamentable moment over which the 42nd
president presided: passage of the "don't ask, don't tell" policy.
"Bill Clinton has been the
first President this nation has ever had to forthrightly, candidly, and in all
but one case successfully attack some of the most basic and virulent
discrimination that persists against gays and lesbians," wrote Bond, now
President Obama's deputy director of the White House Office of Public
Engagement.
As Gay Pride Month
draws to a close today, pundits, community leaders, and activists are
evaluating anew President Obama's own advocacy -- how the accomplishments that the
administration has already achieved, and continues to achieve, should be
weighed against his current marriage stance, one that Freedom to Marry founder
and attorney Evan Wolfson has said is "wrong -- historically, constitutionally,
politically, and morally."
The president
struck a confident tone during Wednesday evening's pride reception remarks at
the White House ("I've met my commitments to the LGBT community"), confidence
reiterated by Bond. "The President is proud of the accomplishments he and his
Administration have achieved for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender people
here and abroad -- accomplishments that have a positive impact on the daily lives
of the LGBT community," he said in a statement. "He looks forward to continuing
that progress in the months and years to come."
The Obama LGBT accomplishment list, featured on a White House Web page launched June
1, contains unquestionable historic victories for gay Americans, including
declaring the Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional, signing "don't ask,
don't tell" repeal into law, and assuring rights to hospital visitation and
medical decisions for LGBT couples. The Democratic National Committee, which
hosted an LGBT Leadership fund-raiser in New York last week, has its own list as well, enumerating accomplishments from the substantive
to the symbolic. "Everybody agrees that we've made more progress at the federal
level in the last two and half years than in the last 250 years combined," DNC
treasurer Andy Tobias said Wednesday morning (the president echoed the
sentiment a few hours later in his news conference, saying that in opposing
discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, "We have done more in the
two and a half years that I've been in here than the previous 43
Presidents"). "At the same time, we all, including the president, want to
see a lot more progress," Tobias added.
Fred Sainz, vice
president of communications for the Human Rights Campaign, which endorsed
Obama's reelection last month, said that LGBT voters will ultimately judge the president on the full body of his accomplishments. While an endorsement for
marriage equality would be a huge symbolic moment, "if the president endorses
marriage, it's not game over," Sainz said. "It's one peg in a larger strategy.
We're also focusing on meaningful legislation, on policy changes, on everything
that will, over time, make the lives of LGBT people better."
Said Marsha Scott, a former deputy assistant to President Clinton and one recipient of the 1996 memo: "Of course I think people do want to see [Obama] reelected. The alternative would be a horrific setback. But he has promised things he is now not able to do." The administration made a historic move in February to no longer defend DOMA in federal court challenges. "Will DOMA be repealed [in this term]? No," Scott said. "Can we change much legislatively now? No. But that doesn't mean this constituency shouldn't continue to hold him accountable."
Some observers say this set of circumstances may mean a continued full-court press on the marriage issue as the summer progresses as well as continuing to clear up the record on what exactly has been accomplished -- even among the more minor "firsts." Speaking last week to The New Civil Rights Movement, an online journal, Paul Yandura, who served as director of gay and lesbian outreach on the Clinton and Gore campaigns and was once executive director of the DNC's LGBT Leadership Council, said the claim that Obama is the first sitting president to attend an LGBT fund-raiser is incorrect -- that President Clinton had attended one in Dallas in 2000 during the end of his presidency (Obama is the first president running for reelection to attend an LGBT fund-raiser, National Public Radio clarified following a story last week).
The DNC's list also touts the Obama White House as the first to send "an administration official to the Senate to testify in favor of the Employment Non-Discrimination Act." Bond's 1996 memo, however, notes that the Clinton administration had sent its own official: "When ENDA was first introduced, in 1993, the Clinton administration sent Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights [now Massachusetts governor] Deval Patrick to testify at the one hearing on the bill in the Senate in support of the principle of non-discrimination against gays and lesbians in the employment context," he wrote.
"It doesn't irk me," Scott said of the accomplishments list. "You do spend the first year and a half working so hard [in the White House], and the closer you get to reelection, the more concentrated you are on touting your boss's successes. Though I'd like to see accuracy" as well as a little more historical context in general, given public polling on support for gay rights causes in 2011 versus the 1990s, she said.
Yandura, whose partner filed suit against the DNC after he was terminated in 2007 (the suit was later settled on undisclosed terms), insists he has not wavered in casting a vote for Obama in 2012.
"But we should look at what he promised versus what is a first. Being a first is a low bar at this point," said Yandura, who runs the Washington, D.C.-based consulting firm Scott and Yandura along with Scott. "Elections are special opportunities to be heard. All we're asking of him is to do what he had promised. To be a fierce advocate. And no one should have any shame in doing so."
Want more breaking equality news & trending entertainment stories?
Check out our NEW 24/7 streaming service: the Advocate Channel!
Download the Advocate Channel App for your mobile phone and your favorite streaming device!
From our Sponsors
Most Popular
Meet all 37 of the queer women in this season's WNBA
April 17 2024 11:24 AM
Here are the 15 gayest travel destinations in the world: report
March 26 2024 9:23 AM
After 20 years, and after tonight, Obama will no longer be the Democrats' top star
August 20 2024 12:28 PM
More Than 50 of Our Favorite LGBTQ+ Moms
May 12 2024 11:44 AM
Conjoined twins Lori Schappell and trans man George Schappell dead at 62
April 27 2024 6:13 PM
Latest Stories
How 'Skincare' tackles women's aging, consent, and othering a queer-coded Latino
September 04 2024 8:00 PM
Here are the 25 transgender Americans lost to violence so far this year
September 04 2024 3:35 PM
Ben Platt marries Noah Galvin in New York celebration
September 04 2024 3:15 PM
53 years ago, Jack Baker and Michael McConnell became the first same-sex couple to wed
September 04 2024 2:27 PM
Even Republicans are against Tennessee’s trans health ban
September 04 2024 1:05 PM
And they're off! 8 things to watch for as the 2024 presidential election kicks into high gear
September 04 2024 10:00 AM
Tim Walz to honor LGBTQ+ community at Human Rights Campaign National Dinner (exclusive)
September 04 2024 9:00 AM
A Virginia college bans transgender students — based on language from the year 1900
September 04 2024 5:39 AM
Harris campaign, others call out Trump for holding events in towns with racist histories
September 04 2024 4:57 AM
Candace Owens claims TikTok makes men gay and causes women to hate them
September 03 2024 6:27 PM
16 LGBTQ+ movies & TV shows to watch in September 2024
September 03 2024 4:21 PM
Transphobic Texas Democrat finds home for bigotry in state Republican Party
September 03 2024 4:07 PM