![Hobbs_leftx390_0](https://www.advocate.com/media-library/hobbs-leftx390-0.jpg?id=32713953&width=1200&height=876)
CONTACTStaffCAREER OPPORTUNITIESADVERTISE WITH USPRIVACY POLICYPRIVACY PREFERENCESTERMS OF USELEGAL NOTICE
© 2024 Pride Publishing Inc.
All Rights reserved
All Rights reserved
By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Private Policy and Terms of Use.
LGBT activists and parents have expressed outrage after the Supreme Court of Ohio upheld lower court rulings that a biological mother who acknowledged her same-sex partner as a co-parent of her daughter while the two women were in a relationship did not permanently give up her sole custody of the child to create legal shared custody with the partner.
The 4-3 decision authored by Justice Robert R. Cupp, affirmed a 1st District Court of Appeals ruling that "competent, credible evidence supported the Hamilton County Juvenile Court's judgment that although Kelly Mullen of Cincinnati shared the responsibilities of parenting her daughter Lucy with former partner Michele Hobbs while the women lived together, Mullen's actions did not confer on Hobbs a permanent right to shared custody of Lucy after her relationship with Mullen ended."
This decision came even as the court acknowledged that the two women had jointly planned Mullen's insemination and pregnancy and shared parental duties; Hobbs had been identified as Lucy's "co-parent" in documents including a ceremonial birth certificate; and Mullen had named Hobbs in her will to act as Lucy's guardian in the event of her death and had also executed general and health care powers of attorney allowing Hobbs to make school, health care, and other decisions for Lucy.
Initially a juvenile court granted Hobbs shared custody but Mullen filed objections to the magistrate's report, pointing out that each of the documents in which she had granted Hobbs some form of "parental" rights over Lucy had been revocable, and that Mullen had in fact revoked them since ending her relationship with Hobbs. She also noted that although Hobbs had suggested executing a written agreement explicitly granting Hobbs shared custody of Lucy on several occasions, Mullen had declined to do so. The court agreed with Mullen, a victory that left many same-sex parents stunned.
"This decision is a tragedy for the child, above all else," said Christopher Clark, senior staff attorney for Lambda Legal's Midwest regional office in Chicago, in a statement. "The court disregarded the overwhelming evidence that Ms. Mullen agreed to parent Lucy with Ms. Hobbs 'in every way.' Regrettably, the decision severs a parent-child relationship between Lucy and the person she knows to be her mother. All Ohio families should be alarmed by this, as a child with a non-biological parent could be taken from their mom or dad in the event of a separation."
Justice Paul E. Pfeifer, in a dissent, wrote that the trial court relied in error upon certain testimony, and that the evidence presented by Hobbs was more than sufficient to establish that Mullen had agreed to cede partial custody to Hobbs. "Can an agreement that another person is a co-parent in every way possibly not include a right to custody? It cannot. The law has not caught up to our culture, and this court has failed to craft a rule that addresses reality. Mullen and Hobbs employed a well-versed lawyer who represents people in their situation, and with his advice did all they could do to protect Hobbs. A maternal relationship existed between Hobbs and Lucy. Mullen taught her daughter to call another woman 'Momma' and to love her as a mother. She now wishes she hadn't, and for the majority, that's enough. It shouldn't be."
deliciousdiane
Want more breaking equality news & trending entertainment stories?
Check out our NEW 24/7 streaming service: the Advocate Channel!
Download the Advocate Channel App for your mobile phone and your favorite streaming device!
From our Sponsors
Most Popular
Meet all 37 of the queer women in this season's WNBA
April 17 2024 11:24 AM
Here are the 15 gayest travel destinations in the world: report
March 26 2024 9:23 AM
After 20 years, and after tonight, Obama will no longer be the Democrats' top star
August 20 2024 12:28 PM
More Than 50 of Our Favorite LGBTQ+ Moms
May 12 2024 11:44 AM
Conjoined twins Lori Schappell and trans man George Schappell dead at 62
April 27 2024 6:13 PM
Latest Stories
White man killed prison cellmate because he was Black and gay, prosecutors allege
September 06 2024 7:20 PM
Father of accused Georgia school shooter claimed son was bullied and called 'gay'
September 06 2024 7:05 PM
Turner Classic Movies spotlights the best political films of all time
September 06 2024 7:05 PM
Transgender Massachusetts teen brutally attacked in possible hate crime
September 06 2024 5:28 PM
Kim Petras' sexy new collab with The Chainsmokers is an instant classic
September 06 2024 4:44 PM
Maryland Republican Neil Parrott is an anti-LGBTQ+ disaster
September 06 2024 1:32 PM
U.S. steps up response to more deadly mpox outbreak
September 06 2024 1:22 PM
Trailblazing women in politics: A historical perspective
September 06 2024 9:00 AM
Dannii Minogue is proud to embrace her status as a gay icon
September 05 2024 6:09 PM
JD Vance lies about Tim Walz and trans kids while courting the far right
September 05 2024 6:04 PM
The Runway of Dreams Foundation to revolutionize fashion with accessible design at NYFW
September 05 2024 5:48 PM
Sade's first new song in years will grace trans-focused album and honor her son
September 05 2024 3:37 PM
Mike Rogers is the anti-LGBTQ+ extremist running for U.S. Senate in Michigan
September 05 2024 3:32 PM
Judge partially halts Idaho’s anti-trans care law
September 05 2024 2:30 PM
Female couples are helping to keep Portland queer
September 05 2024 1:27 PM
How 'Skincare' tackles women's aging, consent, and othering a queer-coded Latino
September 04 2024 8:00 PM
Here are the 25 transgender Americans lost to violence so far this year
September 04 2024 3:35 PM
Ben Platt marries Noah Galvin in New York celebration
September 04 2024 3:15 PM
53 years ago, Jack Baker and Michael McConnell became the first same-sex couple to wed
September 04 2024 2:27 PM
Trending stories
Most Recent
Recommended Stories for You
Diane Anderson-Minshall
Diane Anderson-Minshall is the CEO of Pride Media, and editorial director of The Advocate, Out, and Plus magazine. She's the winner of numerous awards from GLAAD, the NLGJA, WPA, and was named to Folio's Top Women in Media list. She and her co-pilot of 30 years, transgender journalist Jacob Anderson-Minshall penned several books including Queerly Beloved: A Love Across Genders.
Diane Anderson-Minshall is the CEO of Pride Media, and editorial director of The Advocate, Out, and Plus magazine. She's the winner of numerous awards from GLAAD, the NLGJA, WPA, and was named to Folio's Top Women in Media list. She and her co-pilot of 30 years, transgender journalist Jacob Anderson-Minshall penned several books including Queerly Beloved: A Love Across Genders.