Politics
Kamala Harris, Pete Buttigieg Disappoint at CNN Town Hall
Sen. Harris tripped up on terminology relating to LGBTQ people, and Buttigieg declined to go in-depth on his policies.Â
April 23 2019 10:39 AM EST
May 31 2023 7:31 PM EST
By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Private Policy and Terms of Use.
Sen. Harris tripped up on terminology relating to LGBTQ people, and Buttigieg declined to go in-depth on his policies.Â
Democratic presidential candidates Kamala Harris and Pete Buttigieg drew shade from queer Twitter following a CNNTown Hall event on Monday night.
Harris delivered a gaffe when she confused, or misspoke about, trans men and women, while Buttigieg failed to prove his policy chops.
California's junior senator was discussing legislation she and her colleagues introduced last year that would ban the use of "gay and trans panic" as criminal defenses in court, but Harris muddled her terminology while describing her position.
"You'll remember the tragic cases involving transgender men who were killed," she said. "There was this defense that was happening in court, where the murderer was calling it the gay panic defense, 'Oh I panicked because I didn't know he was gay, and therefore I should not be convicted of murder."
But it seems Harris meant to reference attacks on transgender women based on the context -- a community that faces a much greater risk of murder.
Many viewers expressed frustration on Twitter moments after this incident.
\u201cIf I did not mishear\u2014and I don\u2019t believe I did\u2014Kamala Harris confused transgender men and transgender women when she referred to the violent effects of \u201cgay panic.\u201d This is not difficult terminology to keep straight, and Harris should know better. #CNNTownHall\u201d— Rachel Vorona Cote (@Rachel Vorona Cote) 1555989812
Many expected the hour-long Town Hall event to show off serious policy positions from the cerebral contender, especially after competitor Sen. Elizabeth Warren spent her week rolling out large policy initiatives.
However, Vox's Ezra Klein noticed the Buttigieg not only dodged policy specifics but seems to say that they are a feature of his candidacy.
\u201cButtigieg responding to a question about why his web site is devoid of policy plans by saying Democrats shouldn't drown voters in the minutia of policy is ridiculous. It's okay to say it's coming soon. It's ludicrous to dismiss the value of policy proposals.\u201d— Ezra Klein (@Ezra Klein) 1555988927
\u201cWhen Buttigieg responded that prisoners should be denied the right to vote, I couldn't help but think of the queer and trans people, many of color, who were incarcerated so that he could have the career and the freedom that he has now. #CNNTownHall\u201d— Raquel Willis (she/her) (@Raquel Willis (she/her)) 1555990571
The candidates will have more opportunities to define and refine their positions at future town hall forums. And some, like Buttigeg, are even trying their luck at Fox News as the race to capture the Democratic nomination intensifies.
Watch the town hall below.